Home / server / Questions / 445340
Accepted
Vazgen
Asked: 2012-11-05 11:10:28 +0800 CST

Microsoft VDI 2012 - VDI Personal collection vs Session-based deployment

  • 772

I have a small confusion about the differences between the 2 types of set ups:

When deploying using Add Roles and Features the Wizard requests to choose from one of two Deployment Scenarios:

  • Virtual machine-based desktop deployment : Virtual machine-based desktop deployment allows users to connect to virtual desktop collections that include published RemoteApp programs and virtual desktops.
  • Session-based desktop deployment : Session-based desktop deployment allows users to connect to session collections that include published RemoteApp programs and session-based desktops.

Although this seems intuitive now, if I continue with "Virtual machine-based desktop deployment" I later have another two options when creating a collection:

  • Pooled virtual desktop collection
  • Personal virtual desktop collection

This is where my confusion lies. What is the differences between a Session-based deployment and Virtual machine-based deployment with Personal virtual desktop collections?

I'm mostly finding information pertaining to Windows Server 2008 but I know there are some core improvements in VDI 2012 so would someone please comment on that.

Thank you

remote-desktop-services

1 Answers

  1. Best Answer

    Session-based

    Session-based refers to Microsoft’s implementation of session virtualisation, isolation which is what was previously called Terminal Services.

    • Each user runs on a server operating system (OS) desktop that is semi-isolated from the other user.
    • Each session shares the same OS kernel.
    • A RDS server is normally a locked down secured environment because configuration changes can affect all users.

    Virtual machine-based

    Virtual machine-based refers to full x86 hardware virtualisation where:

    • Each virtual machine runs separate virtualised hardware that is then interpreted and mapped to physical hardware. This runs on one or more Hyper-V servers.
    • Each client connects to a separate operating system environment running a client OS like Windows 8.
    • Client Oss are normally secured the same as a regular Management Operating Environment (MOE) base changes don’t affect other users because they run in a separate OS instance.

    The different between Pooled and Personal for Virtual machine-based is that:

    1. Pooled shares VMs between users. When a user logs off that VM is available for another person to use or can be rebuilt. This is good for regular users that use a lot of the same applications. http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/dd883265(v=ws.10).aspx
    2. A Personal VM is only used for one user. This is good for power users that require specific applications that might be manually installed. http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/dd883277(v=ws.10).aspx

    This link and it’s sub-links give some examples: http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/hh831447.aspx

    Also see:

    Hope that helps.

    • 7