Home / server / Questions / 544963
In Process
c4f4t0r
Asked: 2013-10-10 11:55:11 +0800 CST

chown with numeric arguments

  • 772

I tried this on Opensuse 12 and Fedora 17, i use the following commans

touch file
chown 777 file
ls -l file
-rw-r--r-- 1 777 root 0 Oct  9 21:43 file
grep 777 /etc/passwd
echo $?
1

There is no user 777

 grep pippo /etc/passwd
 echo $?
 1
 chown pippo file
 chown: invalid user: `pippo'

But if i use non-existing user, i get one error.

Why can i use numeric non-existing user with chown, but not with names?

linux

1 Answers

  1. Why can i use numeric non-existing user with chown, but not with names?

    Because a username must be resolved to a UID, so if the user does not exist no resolution can occur, whereas a UID is a terminating type (it describes itself without resolution).

    Technically all chown requests by the operating system must be done against a UID. The username is for your benefit, not the operating system.

    • 10