I have a wide open security group which I rely on for instances to be able to connect. I also have a private network of 172.*. addresses, as shown here:
What do I need to do in order to allow servers launched with the same subnet id to talk to one another? Currently, they can ssh to each other, but they cannot ping - even though I have opened up all firewall rules.
Ping uses the ICMP protocol, not TCP.
Routing tables are not involved in intra-subnet communication, unless you meant security groups.