Home / server / Questions / 698251
Accepted
StanTastic
Asked: 2015-06-12 02:51:46 +0800 CST

How does the DNS protocol switch from UDP to TCP?

  • 772

Before anyone asks: I've seen When do DNS queries use TCP instead of UDP? and it doesn't answer my question.

All I keep hearing is "if the answer is too long, DNS will use TCP". This does not explain how it happens though.

So here's the situation: DNS client asks for resolution of a record using UDP. The record is too long for UDP:

  1. server answers with specific opcode, to have client switch to TCP
  2. server doesn't answer at all, and client re-tries over TCP
  3. server opens TCP connection to client (stupid, if you count NAT, but who knows?)
  4. client somehow (?) 'knows' that given query should be run over TCP so it doesn't bother with UDP in the first place
  5. DNS pixies magically turn UDP into TCP when needed

I've been looking all over the internet for the answer, but there's lot of noise (see above), and I can't seem to write proper Google query for that (nor can I find the info in RFCs, for that matter).

domain-name-system

1 Answers

  1. Best Answer

    The client does not know in advance that the response will be too large, so it will query the server via UDP.
    The server will respond via UDP and will include as much as possible and set the truncated header bit ("TC" http://www.networksorcery.com/enp/protocol/dns.htm).
    The client can then resend the request via TCP and get the full response.

    See also: https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc5966

    In the absence of EDNS0 (Extension Mechanisms for DNS 0) (see below), the normal behaviour of any DNS server needing to send a UDP response that would exceed the 512-byte limit is for the server to truncate the response so that it fits within that limit and then set the TC flag in the response header. When the client receives such a response, it takes the TC flag as an indication that it should retry over TCP instead.

    And: https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2181.txt

    And as mentioned in the comments, of course DNS zone transfers are always using TCP.

    • 51