I'm sure I'm just missing a step, but I can't figure out how to get server to resolve to new elastic IP address. I appreciate everyone for their help. I've been trying to figure this out for a while now and can't seem to get it.
This is the response for IP Address 2 when typing IP directly into the browser (New Elastic IP Address)
This is the correct response that I'm getting with IP Address 1
Here's the settings for my instance. As you can see it has IP Address 1 as the public and elastic IP addresses:
Here's the security settings for "WebServerSG" security group.
And here's the elastic IP settings where you can see that IP Address 2 is set to the VPC and the instance and also you can see the private IP address that's referenced as the secondary IP addresses field of my instance details.